Friday, 20 December 2024

Agatha All Along S01E09 Review: No One Mourns The Wicked

Agatha All Along, Season 1, Episode 9: Maiden Mother Crone


And now, for the season finale. Whereas the previous episode gave us the big superhero-vs-supervillain punch-up, "Maiden, Mother, Crone" takes a bit of an interesting twist on the superhero show formula by giving us an emotional end... and a superhero's origin story. Done far more effectively than the rather embarrassingly shoehorned attempt they did more recently in Echo, with the simple fact that for a show whose original performance hinges almost entirely on the actress's performance as a secondary character in a previous show, Agatha All Along has managed to hook me along the journey down the Witches' Road. 

I don't think it's a perfect show like what a lot of Agatha All Along's most vocal supporters have been hailing this as. There's still a fair bit of questionable decisions and underdeveloped characters. But it most certainly delivered more than what I expected. Which is a huge win, especially with the recent state of Disney-Marvel. It was far more entertaining than Echo, than She-Hulk, than What If season two, and most certainly than Secret Invasion.

Of course, we still do have to talk about this final episode, which is a bit of a flashback and a coda to the previous episode. I did complain last episode that one of the show's bigger weakness was that in a bid to keep Rio "Lady Death" Vidal mysterious, she remains frustratingly a cipher. And... we get a flashback to 1750-era Agatha Harkness, who's about to give birth in a random forest when Rio shows up. The two are already familiar with each other, and Agatha begs, begs for all she's worth for Rio to please let his child live. Rio gives Agatha's child time, and then she's gone. 

And we go through a bit of a slow montage as Agatha's child, Nicholas Scratch, grows up. Nicky is used by Agatha as a way to get into witch covens, to lure witches out of taverns, to pose as a sickly mom and her child... before she kills witches to absorb their power. Nicholas is young, but even as a young boy he is sometimes confused on why they can't just hang around with the witches. Agatha's response, of course, is to immediately respond that no, they have to kill the witches before they kill her. As the show seems to heavily imply, it's more of a defense mechanism that Agatha herself refuses to entertain the thought of ever shutting off... which may or may not be true, really. 

We also get the genesis of 'The Ballad of Witches' Road', because it's apparently a song that Agatha made up for his own son to sing... with the important distinction that some of the words were there to refer to the two of them -- 'coven two', instead of 'coven true', for example. It's... it's the third episode in a nine-episode season that relied on the song as a climax, which really kind of made me wish that one of the previous iterations of the song hadn't been a full performance in a way. 

And the two are happy... but then at some point death's extra allotted time is up, and while Agatha sleeps, Rio takes Nicholas away. A peaceful death, which elicited a reaction that was anything but from Agatha. But as Agatha buries Nicholas, a young witch shows up... and apparently Agatha's traipsing across the countries have led to a distorted myth spread all across the witch community that there is such a thing called the Witches' Road, and that is where Agatha is trying to gain ultimate power. And Agatha uses this... to kill more and more witches. This was how she got as powerful as she was circa-WandaVision, and this was exactly what she was planning to do in the season premiere before the Witches' Road actually manifested. 

And... again, it's a story that doesn't really hold up, I think, under scrutiny. Agatha and Rio's interaction in episode one is perhaps the biggest question mark I have that can only be handwaved with 'they're exes, eh?' and I also find it rather hard that no one's ever fact-checked that the Witches' Road is real or not... but it does explain a lot of Agatha's irreverence towards the Road compared to the other witches, and it's a neat enough twist. 

Of course, in the present day, Wiccan is visited by the ghost of Agatha. Because of course you can't keep a good main character down, and while the show is vague on whether this was a deal that she made with Rio/Death or if it's something else, she's a ghost for now, spotting a more traditional-comics accurate appearance. Wiccan is horrified at the idea that he made the Road and led indirectly to the deaths of Alice, Lilia and Sharon... but Agatha gives a rather backhanded reassurance that Wiccan actually saved Jen in a certain point of view, since Agatha would've killed all four of them without a second thought if the Witches' Road didn't appear. I like that at least Agatha's psychopathy is kept around, even when she's in this more cooperative form. 

Wiccan attempts to banish Agatha with her magic, which could also be a good closing to this series, to have Agatha be punished, in some way, for all of her villainy. But she refuses to go, seemingly by nothing but sheer force of will... and in perhaps one of the few honest lines she's had this series, she yells that she can't face 'him', or Nicholas. Wiccan is shaken just a bit by that... but Agatha immediately turns around and offers her services as a spirit guide. They could, after all, make a good team to continue Wiccan's journey to find Tommy, wherever he ended up. They set off together into a glowing portal, and the series ends. 

And... that's it for Agatha All Along. It's an unconventional end to an unconventional series. It's experimental, it's weird, it's not perfect, but you could really feel that it's made with passion and care. That the actors wanted to be there, that they knew which parts of the story they wanted to tell the audience. I wasn't particularly optimistic about this show when I came in to it, but at the end of it, I was pleasantly surprised. 

Marvel Easter Eggs Corner:
  • Agatha's ghostly appearance at the end -- in a purple dress with white hair -- is how she looks in the comics, both in the older comics and in modern, post-WandaVision ones. She also served as a ghostly spirit guide (albeit a much more traditional and less snarky one) to Scarlet Witch in the comics. 
  • Nicholas Scratch is Agatha's grandson in the comics. However, unlike his relatively harmless appearance here, comics!Scratch is a full-blown villain. 

Tuesday, 17 December 2024

Reviewing Fan-Pokemon: Pokemon Infinite Fusion, Part 7 -- Mimikyu Edition

After Porygon, I decided to randomly pick one of the other 'themed' Infinite Fusion templates that I said I wanted to do. It was either the Duskull line, the Grimer line, the Solosis line, Cofagrigus, Unown or Mimikyu. (I didn't want to do the Klink line back-to-back with Porygon). 

Obviously, Mimikyu won! And... I do like it. One thing that I wasn't really feeling with the Porygon one was that... a lot of the fusions are samey, so it's a bit hard for me to say stuff without repeating myself too much. Mimikyu's whole deal is that he wears a felt-cloth costume of other Pokemon, so there's inherently a lot more adorable variation going on here, as well as some more twisted ones. 

Again, similar introduction to the rest of the Infinite Fusion posts --  Infinite Fusion is a fan-game that features fusions of Pokemon as the gimmick, and often times this includes some excellent sprite-work by artists. 

I did a more in-depth explanation of the fusion process in the first review. Basically, the Infinite Fusion calculator has two different combinations, with one Pokemon as the body, and the other Pokemon as the head + colours, and vice-versa. But the most interesting ones are the crowdsourced custom sprites for the fusions, the bulk of which is what we'll be talking about here!
____________________________________________


A lot of the 'Mimikyu as the base body' fusions very understandably just switches out the Pikachu base of the felt-cloth puppet with whatever Pokemon it's fused with. And it's honestly something I kind of wished Pokemon did as regional variants -- surely this makes more sense than giving us seven different outfits for Pikachu? 

The starters and baby Pokemon make for some really adorable ones, and I love the creativity that gose into the concept of Mimikyu making these cosplays out of scrap material. Mimikyu/Turtwig here is pretty basic, but I like that just like regular Mimikyu's wooden Pikachu tail, the leaf prop he's using for Turtwig's head is falling off. Meanwhile, Mimikyu/Cyndaquil inherits Cyndaquil's slit-like eyes, and this one apparently managed to get a fake flame effect behind him. Is it cardboard? It's probably cardboard. 


Some more cure ones. Mimikyu/Torchic is pretty dang cute, and I featured Mimikyu/Mudkip in a previous post. Mimikyu/Jigglypuff goes a bit more anime with it, with the face being scribbled on with a blue felt-tip marker, and it's even holding a microphone with its ghost hand. I feel like a Jigglypuff Mimikyu would be adorable as it tries to sing, but people get freaked out by its face. 


We've got Mimikyu/Pichu and Mimikyu/Raichu. I really think the Pichu fusion is really cute! The Raichu one is... uh... yeah, that scribbled-on face does look a bit disturbing, despite it trying to mimic regular Raichu's mouth instead of the creepy psycho zigzag that canon Mimikyu has. I like that the tail is still a wooden or cardboard chunk. 

We'll get another couple of simple, cute ones out of the way. Mimikyu/Squirtle and Mimikyu/Chimchar. I'm not the biggest fan of Chimchar (I'm not a big fan of monkeys in general) and so I think this design is infinitely better than the actual monkey. A whole bunch of wholesomeness!

Honestly, though, these feel less like proper 'fusions' and more like just creative variants of Mimikyu. Which, by the way, is not a complaint. I'd love for a region to have like 30 different Mimikyu variants. It sure would be more appealing to collect than like 30 different Vivillons or Alcremies!


Some of these really do get creative! It's not always just a felt-cloth doll like canon Mimikyu. Mimikyu/Tentacruel here makes its disguise with a blue trash can, with scribbles to represent the red orbs on Tentacruel. It completes its disguise with a bunch of black felt tape, and a sharp 'beak' or 'nose' that seems obviously glued on. It's probably fitting that it's made out of pollution too, you could probably guess that this guy hung out near the oceans. 

Mimikyu/Gyarados also gets creative! Always love any design that has two glowing eyes peering out of a black abyss of a mouth, and it makes perfect sense here since Mimikyu's using a costume for the Gyarados. But Mimikyu's true shadow form is holding the little stick that keeps the Gyarados body up, as if it's like a dragon dance in a Chinese New Year festival. That's pretty cute. I like the little stitched-up seam running down Gyarados's body as well! 

The bases that use the other Pokemon as the 'main' body also can be really cool because... guess what? Mimikyu himself is pretty damn cool! The effect is kind of amplified with already spooky Pokemon, like Misdreavus/Mimikyu here. We keep most of Misdreavus's anatomy, but she now has jet-black, hollow eyes and stitches running up and down her now presumably felt body. And of course we've got Mimikyu's usual giant shadow claw jutting out from beneath her body. 

I'm not sure why I find Mimikyu/Politoed here a bit more unsettling. I guess it's that stitched-up grin and the black button-eyes? I like that the 'leaf' on Politoed's head is also clearly salvaged from some plant or other. I kind of headcanon some of these other-Pokemon-as-the-base-body fusions as a Mimikyu with a better costume, so much that it doesn't have to scuttle around in the somewhat conical shape that traditional Mimikyu does. 

Chandelure/Mimikyu is another pretty interesting one in that the design seems to be adapting Mimkyu's inner shadow form taking the form of the traditional chandelier. I like that it's got a bunch of goopy wax everywhere, and that there are chunks of Mimikyu's original Pikachu-based costume that lay tattered around the chandelier hands. 

I like Klinklang/Mimikyu here, where the real Mimikyu's this shadowy pair of hands using yellow strings to puppeteer a bunch of rusty gears arranged in the rough shape of a Klinklang. The puppeteer strings isn't exactly what a Mimikyu is themed after, but using scrap as a costume still fits with what this little guy is doing! 





As per tradition, we need to see what the 'squared' fusion is, and Mimikyu/Mimikyu is... just a Gigantamax Pikachu version of Mimikyu. I guess it makes sense! I didn't find this as funny as I should, but it's a good gag. 

Mimikyu/Pikachu is interesting. At first glance it just seems like it's a reverse cosplay -- a Pikachu wearing a Mimikyu hoodie. I think Pokemon Go even has a PIkachu costume like this. But we've got an actual Mimikyu shadow tendril claw peeking up from underneath that skirt, so who knows what's going on under there? 


Mimikyu/Cradily is adorable as all hell! Neither Cradily nor Mimikyu has those massive giant chompers in the green maw, but it doesn't feel out of place. Mimikyu's eyes glint within the dark void, while -- just like canon Cradily -- two yellow buttons act as fake 'eyes'. It's such a clever adaptation of the real Cradily's fake eye-spots and real eyes. And, of course, he's got a bunch of socks that are used as the materials for Cradily's tentacles. 

Big daddy satan Mimikyu/Giratina also looks pretty fun! We've got a small cosplay of Giratina as a puppet, but instead of a formless glob bursting out as a shadowy appendage, we've got a full-on monstrosity with tendril-ribcage-claws just like the Origin Forme of Giratina. Pretty cool! 


More cuties! Man, there's a lot less 'creepy' Mimikyu fusions than I thought! I'm actually quite surprised, but I guess the Pokemon fandom recognizes Mimikyu as a cute baby that needs to be protected. Mimikyu/Pidgeot here doesn't quite have the same 'this costume is cobbled from trash' vibe that most of the Mimikyu fusions have, but I love that face. I can't not put this little guy in this page.

Mimikyu/Dusclops is just adorable, okay? Dusclops is based on a paper lantern, so it's already ripe to become a Pokemon 'made out of trash', but I love how this Mimikyu goes around completing the look, with what looks like goopy wax or cream to make Dusclops' tail, and two little white pom-poms on sticks to represent Dusclops' hands. That's adorable. 


Mimikyu/Roselia here is adorable! Look at it. It's got the Roselia body down pat, with stitches and duct tapes, but what gets me the most is that he's using two differently-coloured sink rags for Roselia's rose arms. 

Appreciate how cute Mimikru/Raikou is. Honestly, regular Raikou already has a tail that looks like it's salvaged from somewhere and glued on! I really do like the face on this one, though, particularly the eyes and the whiskers. 


Ponyta/Mimikyu is just a rocking horse! That's cute. I love that we still have canon Mimikyu's wooden tail, but the wood's extended to the horse feet and handles as well. I like that Mimikyu's using his shadow hand as the 'fiery' mane of this rocking horse, too. 

This one goes a bit more 'meta', but Mimikyu/Krookodile literally has Mimikyu hold up a cardboard cutout of the game screen's format, with HP bar and everything. 


Mimikyu/Umbreon is a pretty cool one, with the Mimikyu entity having created a whole Umbreon suit, but since it's a bit more complex compared to its little Pikachu cosplay, Umbrekyu here has to use its shadow hands to puppeteer the Umbreon entity. Love it. 

Mimkyu/Shuckle is another one that uses a bunch of creative trash to create a fascimile of the creature. In this case, it's some guy's biker helmet serving as Shuckle's shell, and a mass of black tendrils ending in yellow socks representing Shuckle's wormy tentacles. That's pretty cool, and I just really like the idea of a biker helmet as a dome-shaped piece of trash that 'naturally' has a lot of holes. 


Mimkyu/Octillery is another cute one, with the main octopus body being made up out of salvaged material. It's not quite as clear as the Tentacruel or Shuckle one what the red material are, but the octopus cannon is definitely a toilet roll, isn't it? The scribble eyes are always cute, too. 

Mimikyu/Kabuto I just really liked the look of. Again, it's not quite clear what Mimito here is making its cosplay out of, but Kabuto's anatomy is already a very distinct shelled creature with a shadowy understide, so it feels natural that Mimikyu would feel at home in a Kabuto cosplay. I like that the shadow arms are replacing Kabuto's upper claws. 


Mimikyu/Dratini is just here because I find it cute! Not much to say, it sure is cute. 

Mimikyu/Gible is a cute one! Its costume is a cardboard box with a bunch of things taped on, like the fin and hammerhead shark greebles, and a bunch of stuff drawn on it. It's another one that I find cute!


As the other 'artificial' Pokemon, Golurk makes for very fun fusions with Mimikyu! The first Mimikyu/Golurk is a Mimikyu hiding within the rift in Golurk's chest, with eyes and claws lurking out of the chest. I like that the regular Golurk eyes are hollow. It's a weird but nice touch that the left arm is wooden, too, and it even looks like this is a golem cobbled together and repaired, not to dissimilar with the concept of Regirock. Pretty neat! Is this a Mimikyu that cobbled together a Golurk golem, or a Mimikyu that infiltrated a dead or empty Golurk?

I just find the reverse to be adorable, a Golurk plushie with mismatched eyes, and Mimikyu's eyes peeking out of the stitched-up seams within. It's just adorable. 


Mimikyu/Ariados is pretty cute! I really like everything that goes on here. Apparently this particular Mimikyu was able to get some more high-quality material in making Ariados's face and legs, but the visual imagery of Mimikyu's regular conical doll body scuttling around on four spidery legs is pretty creepy-cute! This Mimikyu should be proud, his cosplay is pretty good. 

Mimikyu/Wailmer is an interesting one, where Wailmer himself is already sorta artificial-looking, being a whale patterned after a beach ball. The spriter decided to re-interpret it into a hot-air balloon... or just a balloon, I guess, with Wailmer's face scribbled hastily onto it. The 'true' Mimikyu is suspended below it, covered in a hilarious cartoonish white sheet like a cartoon ghost. I do really like the end result. It's not quite a 'proper' fusion but I like the creativity that goes into this. 

Saturday, 14 December 2024

Agatha All Along S01E08 Review: Ding Dong, The Witch Is Dead

Agatha All Along, Season 1, Episode 8: Follow Me My Friend; To Glory At The End


It has been the formula for Marvel TV shows to have the final episode be a substitute to the big (often CGI-laden) punch-up between the main hero and the main antagonist. That worked for some shows -- for WandaVision, for Moon Knight, for Hawkeye, for the first season of What If?... but it didn't, for some. Ms. Marvel's huge emotional and narrative climax happened in its penultimate episode, and the big fight in the final episode felt superfluous. She-Hulk attempted to subvert this by explicitly refusing to do a huge punch-up with the antagonists that it tried to set up, but whatever the She-Hulk final episodes are, they most certainly aren't a satisfying conclusion. 

Agatha All Along's first season, meanwhile, has what's basically a two-parter conclusion, and I am genuinely surprised to see that the big action scenes are done and dusted in the penultimate one. And... it's an interesting way to tackle the ending of one of Marvel's more unconventional shows. 

Which is why we're starting with the supposed 'focus' character of this episode, Rio Vidal, a.k.a. the Green Witch, a.k.a. the cosmic entity Lady Death. We start off with her walking and escorting Alice to the afterlife, showing that despite her over-the-top mannerisms and taunting, she is still the cosmic manifestation of death. Terrifying, but ultimately also the friend that greets you at the end of the road that is life. 

After Lilia's death at the end of the previous episode, Rio and Agatha finally confront each other after Rio's brief absence. Rio gives us her motivation -- she wants the 'scales balanced', because Wiccan is an 'abomination' that shouldn't be alive. As a cosmic entity, Rio refuses to let him roam around in the world of the living... much less summon another thing that should not be alive in Billy's brother. However, there is a bit of a complication. Thanks to the uniqueness of the magic that created the entity that is Wiccan, he can't exactly die. He has to come willingly with Death, otherwise he'll just continue reincarnating to the next corpse and the next corpse.

And throughout this episode, the main focus and character lynchpin is Agatha Harkness herself, which is quite appropriate. Throughout her run in this show and in WandaVision, Agatha has been defined by her sheer 'gives no shits' attitude. She doesn't care about any of her coven, she views everyone else as stepping stones to her ambition... but Wiccan is the one sole exception that she seems to care about. And, of course, Agatha gives the easiest self-defense as Rio demands Wiccan... "take him". They make a deal, with Agatha not ever wanting to see Rio ever again (and even when she dies long, long in the future, she doesn't want to see Rio's face). In a cool bit of magic mindfuckery, Rio uses her knife to cut the sky as if it's the background in a stage show, and walks through it. 

With only three members in the coven left, Agatha, Wiccan and Jennifer continue the trial. They end up at the beginning of the Road, discovering that it's a circle. Wiccan throws a temper tantrum, putting the shoes he took off out of respect for the Witches' Road back on... and they end up in a morgue, struggling out of body bags. This is the episode's very short trial, which is supposed to be assigned to the 'earth' or 'green' magic of Rio.

As everyone panics while the timer counts down, Agatha accidentally lets slip the fact that she was the one behind Jen's curse 100 years ago, although Agatha never knew the target of the spell. Jen grabs Agatha's hair, chants an unbinding spell, regains her power and disappears from the Witches' Road. It's... it's really bizarre. It is a conclusion to Jen's story arc, I suppose, but the character has been on the sidelines so much that I barely mustered caring about her. We get to see her float off all alive and well into the distance at either the end of this episode or the next one, and I really don't care all that much, unfortunately. She just got interesting here, and I really would've liked this revelation to happen earlier in the season -- maybe episode 3 or 4 or something, and then we could've had an antagonistic Jen for the second half of the season... but it really did feel like the showrunners just wanted her out of their hair while we focus on the primary three protagonists.

Agatha guides Wiccan to look for what he wants from the Road. Jen wanted her power back, and Wiccan wants his brother back. Agatha coaches Wiccan as he looks for a suitable body, which, of course, coincidentally is a dead boy who's also called Tommy (most likely from a family called the Shepherds) who's drowning in a pool due to a terrifyingly irresponsible prank. Wiccan is confused about it all, asking Agatha if he's killing this other boy so his brother can live... but he never gets to hear Agatha's answer as he blips out of the Road. So yeah, Speed at some point in the future, I guess. 

Agatha manages to figure out something to get life to grow or whatever, pulling out a dandelion seed from the locket with her son's hair that she's been wearing all season, and manages to unlock the doors to the trial room and she explodes out of the cellar door in her Westview house. Rio/Death is waiting for her, and here we have the final battle. Rio is pissed off that she didn't get Wiccan, so she's attacking Agatha with some magical blasts. Agatha dodges an initial kill-shot thanks to one of Lilia's last parting words, before Wiccan arrives in his full suprehero outfit glory. Which... is... all right? It's not the best Disney+ superhero outfit, but it's all right for what it is. 

Wiccan fights Rio a bit, but then they realize that Agatha needs her magic back. And this is what the show has kind of building up to throughout the season. Is Agatha capable of not being a selfish prick for once in her life? Wiccan, always a nice bleeding heart, unleashes his magic on Agatha, knowing very well that Agatha could do the same parasitic drain she did on Alice. But despite some moments where it looks like Agatha's about to betray Wiccan, she doesn't. Agatha Harkness returns in her full glory, dressed up in her WandaVision climax outfit. And then we get a bit more of a fight before they realize that Lady Death is way too powerful for them, and one of them needs to die.

We get a darkly comedic sequence of Bugs-Bunny-ing, as Agatha offers to sacrifice herself, then Wiccan offers himself... and Agatha agrees almost immediately. The heartbreaking expression on Wiccan's face is perfectly acted, and this seems to be the next in a series of moments in this episode on the question of whether Agatha Harkness can care at all. Agatha walks away, with her full power, willing to leave Wiccan in the tender hands of Death... and then Wiccan asks a bombshell of a question. "Is this how Nicky died?"

We've had hints of Nicholas Scratch throughout the show, although frustratingly never anything concrete. It's clear that there's a bit more than meets the eye instead of just Agatha sacrificing Nicholas for power. And we get again, another very well-acted dialogueless scene of Agatha going through so many emotions in her mind as she tries to process this accusation. She doesn't try to defend herself, not with her usual biting sarcasm or any kind of earnest pleading... but she did finally change. She walks up to Rio, kisses her in the mouth, and allows Rio to kill her and spare Wiccan. 

Boom. The final fight. Agatha Harkness, the titular character, dies in one episode before the end. Our main antagonist Lady Death flutters off, her goals accomplished. We get a short scene of Wiccan returning to his house and explaining to his parents (mostly offscreen) what he's been doing in the past couple of days... before he walks into his room and sees a lot of suspiciously familiar things in his room. The heavy implication, of course, just like how Scarlet Witch was behind the creation of everything in the Westview shows, Wiccan was the creator of the Witches' Road unconsciously. And then he gasps in an admittedly lame cliffhanger, and we cut to credits.

And... there are some complaints that I do have about this show so far. The antagonists just aren't that interesting, with the Salem Seven being taken off the board before they even had the chance to be interesting; and the establishing of Rio as Death being so rapid that we never really learn too much about her. Oh, and the rules of witch magic is always frustratingly vague as ever (didn't Agatha gain some power from killing Alice?), and I had my complaint about Jen earlier. But I do feel like the show did a great job at building up the Agatha/Wiccan relationship, as well as establishing just what a gigantic douchebag Agatha is and how willing she is to normally kill people and leave a trail of dead witches in her wake. Having this climactic finale an episode before the end of the season is pretty well-done, and while it's not a perfect climax, I felt that it's one that fit the show almost perfectly. 

Marvel Easter Eggs Corner:
  • Wiccan's costume is based on his most iconic outfit from Young Avengers, albeit with a tiara that resembles his mother's and an additional hoodie. 
  • Right before she dies, Agatha wears her outfit from WandaVision, symbolizing her coming to full power. 

Wednesday, 11 December 2024

Bleach TYBW E33 Review: twin kings vs. vollstAndig

Bleach, Thousand-Year Blood War, Episode 33: Gate of the Sun


So this is an episode that I did not expect to happen at all. I expected a bunch of extended scenes for the climactic fights that we were robbed off -- Ichigo versus Uryu, Ichigo versus Juhabach. I also expected for extensions of fights that were interrupted or very short in the manga, like the extended Squad Zero fight we got.

But "Gate of the Sun" was such a surprising addition in that everything here is brand-new. The matchup was never even really alluded to in the manga, and there wasn't a lot of pre-release hype and foreshadowing like the Ichigo/Uryu confrontation that the story and the various openings had built up a lot. Half of the episode is a hodgepodge of various scenes from the manga as the Silbern invasion starts, but the second half is all-new and I am genuinely surprised -- but pleasantly so -- by it. 

Anyway, the episode starts off still with the epic introduction of Silbern from the previous episode, with the six members of the elite guard being sent off by Juhabach to greet the guests to his new world. They then summon the Gates of the Sun, which we actually see in the anime version. The Gates are giant glowing portal-gates that appear below everyone's feet and allow them to teleport around the Wahrwelt! The five Schutzstaffel are deployed, and disappear into the gates.

We check in a bit with Kyoraku's group, and in a bit of an extended scene, we get to see the three rogue Sternritters depart from the Shinigami. And we get the running scenes as both Kyoraku and Ichigo's group on different parts of Wahrwelt are running towards Silbern. There's a really cool group shot showing everyone that they brought up to the Soul Palace! And... it is of course more of the author splitting the characters up, but I absolutely love it that it took them a while to realize that two of their strongest fighting forces, Mayuri and Kenpachi, are missing. Not even the likes of Urahara or Kyoraku realize this, and it's gloriously and monumentally stupid of them.

Mayuri, meanwhile, has recalibrated their portal-gate thing in order to get away from everyone else. Mayuri just wants to test out the results of his research without being bothered by the rest of the Gotei 13, but of course he's not the only person to pop up -- Zaraki Kenpachi show up behind him. Mayuri is utterly flabbergasted at the random appearance of Kenpachi, but apparently Kenpachi was just using the toilet and was left behind. Somehow. Somehow, the strongest physical warrior on their employ was left in the bathroom. See, decisions like this was why you Shinigami lost the first invasion!

Also, confirmation that Zaraki Kenpachi washes his hands after doing his business. I found it funny that they took the time to confirm this. 

Kenpachi is followed by his two lieutenants Ikkaku and Yumichika, and, of all people, Yamada Hanataro. Which is so random. Hanataro kind of disappears after this scene, and the volume releases would have little omakes that show Hanataro being knocked unsconscious off-screen during the initial salvoes of attacks between Mayuri and Pernida... I highly doubt that he'll actually get to do anything in the anime adaptation, though. 

Kenpachi and Mayuri then do the most weird catfighting. Both of them are psychothic in their own way, and both of them acknowledge that they're on the same side while also acknowledging that the other party is resistant enough to withstand a couple of collateral damage. I like it. The sheer differences in their attitude towards battle is really fun to behold. Both Kenpachi and Mayuri had been my favourite captains back when I was reading this manga, and I remembered seeing this banter between them was amazing. 

We then cut to Team Ichigo, where Grimmjow almost prophetically notes that trying to regroup and move as a large group will just hamper their survivability. All the while, he's just refusing to run alongside his allies and he's just parkouring on the Wahrwelt rooftops. Their group encounters Sternritter "D", Askin Nakk Le Vaar, and I absolutely love the very self-aware reaction that Askin has to seeing Ichigo and team charging towards him. It's almost as if Askin knows Ichigo is the main character or something, because he bemoans his bad luck... just as Grimmjow is already mid-leap towards him and unleashes a gigantic crash that blows up half the building. 

We then get an adaptation of a scene that takes place a bit later in the manga (this would take place in the middle of the three main Schutzstaffel fight -- essentially explaining where Gerard is while the Haschwalth/Bazz-B, Pernida/Mayuri and Kyoraku/Lille fights were happening). Gerard skids to a halt and roars in frustration at his bad luck and tries to goad the Shinigami into all attacking him at once. Overlooking Silbern, we get an additional scene of Bazz-B, Liltotto and Giselle discuss their situation a bit, which foreshadows the eventual confrontation. I do wonder whether Liltotto and Giselle are going to get more to do, since in the manga them tagging along so much amounted to a fat load of nothing. 

Cutting back to Team Ichigo, we get a brief argument between Ichigo and Grimmjow, with Grimmjow being cocky at the thought of having actually beaten one of the super-scary enemies. Askin is still alive, though, and both the animation team and his voice actor clearly love Askin as much as I do, giving him a lot of highlight as he runs away comically. He's pulling a Joseph Joestar! We get a very faithful recreation of the comedic chase scene through the alleyways of Wahrwelt as Askin refusing to stop and gives one-liners like "I'll only stop if you promise not to kill me", and later on trying to get Grimmjow to work with him to fight Ichigo. Again, a combination of the voice-acting, the expressions and the animation all really help to make Askin's super-trolly behaviour work well here.

The animation adds a couple of fun moments not originally in the manga, like having Askin run-backwards while pointing finger-guns at Grimmjow at one point; and making it a bit more clear that Grimmjow has some kind of partial-Resurrección form where he just morphs the tips of his hands to boost his speed.

The most important scene in this whole sequence is kept, of course, which is Askin seemingly getting Grimmjow off of his trail as he looks at Ichigo from the edge of a building, pulls a thermos out of nowhere and just mutters about his "cafe au lait". We lost the picnic basket during the Gremmy/Kenpachi fight, so I am very happy that in this very Askin-centric half-episode, we get to see Askin's antics with the cafe au lait. 

With almost-perfect comedic timing, Grimmjow catches up to Askin and forces him to run again. Askin then yells that he's going to give Grimmjow a gift, and launches a Gift Ball. Grimmjow slashes through the ball while yelling at Askin... which is pretty stupid especially since Grimmjow's dialogue indicates that he knows that Askin is playing him. But then, Grimmjow is never the brightest bulb. The pieces of the Gift Ball splatter over Grimmjow, and he collapses to the ground. Askin stops his pathetic running and goes straight into smarmy asshole mode, crowing at Grimmjow and asking if he's ever taught to avoid gifts as a child. As a Adjuchas-turned-Vasto-Lorde Hollow made by the amalgamation of hundreds of souls, no, Askin, I don't think Grimmjow ever had a parent to teach him that. Or a childhood, for that matter. Later on, during the second-half episode fight, we get a brief continuation of this scene as Ichigo shows up with his blades drawn to confront Askin. 

We then cut away to Lille Barro, who is looking through the scope as the Shinigami runs through the street. Lille gives a badass monologue about how the group is breaking up due to each individual's stamina, skill and pre-existing injuries, and identifies the weakest link in the group... Hisagi Shuhei. Just like in the manga, Lille takes aim... and opens fire, blowing a very inglorious hole through Shuhei's arms and torso. Sorry, better luck next time, Shuhei. 

What's not in the manga, however, is the brutal next series of shots. 2nd Division Vice-Captain Omaeda runs back to help Shuhei, and Lille continues his monologue as we follow his crosshairs, and bang, Omaeda goes down. We don't even get a close-up for Omaeda, which unfortunately is pretty consistent with Omaeda having his otherwise quite significant amount of screentime in the manga absolutely cut down in the anime. 

Next one to go down? Sweet, sweet Kotetsu Kiyone, third-seat of the 13th Division. Her death is insanely brutal-looking. We know she survives, yes, but it sure as hell looks like she just died, with a giant bloody hole punched through the center of her chest as she looks down in horror. Running towards her are her sister, 4th Division Vice-Captain Kotetsu Isane and her co-third-seat Kotsubaki Sentaro... who both immediately get sniped by Lille as well. 

Bang, bang, bang, bang, bang. Five down, just like that. 

In the manga's version of events, it was just Shuhei, and when we check in with the group later on, Shinji and Kyoraku would just discuss that the sniper 'took out some of them', with the manga not making it immediately clear who got taken out, making it super confusing when the Visored show up briefly for an action scene later on, or the implication that super-speedy assassin Captain Soi Fon (who disappears from the manga from this point) was apparently taken out as well. Soi Fon is not, and hopefully she'll be able to participate in one of the battles and be taken out in a way that befits a Captain. I love this scene. It's a bit more shocking, a bit more brutal, and honestly none of these characters are going to really do anything and seeing anyone that's not a Captain or a Visored picked off like flies is a pretty grim reminder that not everyone here is on the same level. 

But as the Shinigami split up, Abarai Renji gets a bunch of regular Quincy arrows fired at him. He slashes through them to see Ishida Uryu as the perpetrator. We get a very nice sequence as Renji just leaps across buildings to reach Uryu, and says the iconic "Roar, Zabimaru" in perhaps the most subdued that the Vice-Captain has ever been. This is a very nice matchup -- Renji is one of the two initial hostile Shinigami that Uryu would've ever met, and the two worked together to fight Szayelaporro during the Espada arc. With Ichigo being the main character, it's easy to focus on his rivalry and relationsihp with Uryu... but I love that when the anime staff decided to give Uryu yet another fight with his allies, they picked Renji. Who, moreso than any of the 'core' friends gang, is one of the two Shinigami -- and the more hostile one to Uryu at that. I also like that Renji is also someone who has rebelled against his own people at one point for a certain cause... just as he was someone who has once forced himself to toe the line of duty and fight Rukia because it was decreed by the Gotei 13. Renji is a deceptively simple character, and I appreciate that he was chosen here to be Uryu's opponent.

Uryu fires another shot at Renji, who dodges it and we get a cool shot of the Heilig Pfeil blowing up a building behind Renji. The two dudes are never about the touchy-feely stuff, and Renji addresses Uryu almost exclusively as 'Quincy' throughout the entire fight. Uryu is also hostile, calling Renji as 'Shinigami' and telling Renji that he's not here to be a guide. Uryu gives Renji some ambiguously double-meaning words, noting that the Shinigami can't defeat Juhabach after he has absorbed the Soul King's power (which also counts as information-dripfeeding as much as it's an antagonistic monologue) and identifies Wahrwelt as a new world made for the Quincies. Upon being asked about Ichigo, Uryu also reveals his previous altercation and vows to kill Ichigo next time they meet. 

The two then fight for real, and we get some nice whipping around of Zabimaru's Shikai form against Uryu's arrows, which is animated really smoothly. As much as I love Uryu and Ichigo's power-sets, Renji's ridiculous-but-badass spiky whip-sword is a really dynamic weapon for these kinds of action scenes. They clash physically for a bit, until Renji unleashes his brand-new Bankai, So'o Zabimaru. Again, just in principle, I love that So'o Zabimaru gets to do a bit more instead of just killing Mask De Masculine -- and as this episode shows off, whatever So'o Zabimaru did in that battle is a mere fraction of the Bankai's full potential. 

Renji then shows off a bunch of new attacks, beginning with Zazekka (Snake Tongue Echo) which essentially turns the thin cutter-blade on his arm into a whip-sword similar to Renji's Shikai... which I thought was a clever way to keep the dynamic whip-blade of the Zabimaru Shikai in this fight. There's a cool animation around this point of Renji using his sandals to deflect one of Uryu's arrows. Renji is also able to swap around parts of his Bankai, attaching the blade to the end of his bone-tail at one point and having it melt through a building in a beautifully-animated sequence. Also, apparently So'o Zabimaru causes fiery explosions now! We see a bit of it in attacks like Hihio Zabimaru's original Hikotsu Taiho beams, or So'o Zabimaru's Zaga Teppo, but this episode's animation makes it clear that Zabimaru is at least partially a heat or flame-based Zanpakuto. That's cool, Renji!

Uryu eventually counters with a rain of Licht Regen, but Renji blocks it with the Hihio arm. He then counterattacks in a cool moment by slamming Hihio against the ground to create a shockwave, then unleashing Orochio to grab a brick and then ram it hard to Uryu. Right through a building! That's a nice sequence, and the force that So'o Zabimaru was slamming Uryu to the buildings is enough to crush walls and create craters. Renji continues with a Hihio punch, driving Uryu to the ground, and follows up with a stab through the stomach, something that is a lot more sudden and brutal compared to the much more reluctant Ichigo. And then Renji unleashes his strongest source material attack, Zaga Teppo, the technique he used to atomize Mask De Masculine. The giant snake head appears and then explodes around Uryu.

The smoke clears... and Uryu is unharmed. Blut Vene is activated, and tells Renji that he, too, has received his upgrade. Uryu transforms into his Vollstandig, though not the full version that we saw when fighting Ichigo -- he's only got the wings and the dagger-feathers. Haschwalth, as always, is watching as this is happening. Uryu combines his feathers into a bow and unleashes a gigantic explosion that Renji does, before continuing to bombard Renji with his minions. Again, it's a bit of a shame, I think, that Uryu's Vollstandig powers is basically a variety on Byakuya's powers. 

As Renji is forced on the back foot this time, he blocks the arrows with Hihio's baboon arm. The flesh and fur seem to get shredded to expose the bone beneath. I was going to make a gag about how Renji unlocked his true Bankai only to have it permanently broken by Uryu after two uses... but turns out that this is a trick. As Uryu walks towards the seemingly fallen Renji, he calls out his technique Hihi Tensho (Baboon Pelt Reincarnation) and the shed fur of Hihio transform into a swarm of giant monkey-skeleton hands that dogpile Uryu.

Renji tells Uryu that he needs 20 seconds -- which itself is a nice nod to a similar sequence where the two of them teamed up to fight Szayelaporro, and Renji had to buy Uryu 20 seconds. This little reference, just like the Shiba Kaien monologue a couple episode back, isn't actually explicitly told to the audience, which I appreciate. Instead, we get a flashback to Renji's training with Ichibei, telling him that thanks to the way that he achieved his true Bankai, he's not experienced in pouring reiatsu into the true form of his Bankai. 

And as this happens, Renji uses the baboon skeleton-arm to grab the snake part of his Bankai, detaching it and spinning it around like how Hihio Zabimaru used to look. Renji then unleashes a brand new tehcnique: Zagai Zekko, Snake Bone's Absolute Roar. Just like a Dragon Ball Z move, Renji charges up a giant fiery ball of reiatsu above him, and unleashes it down upon Uryu in a massive explosion that creates a mini-nuke that is felt by even other characters running around Wahrwelt.

Renji looms over Uryu in the resulting crater, noting that this is nothing personal... which I honestly believe, particularly with how Renji behaved during the whole Rukia affair. Of course, this isn't quite over. Uryu activates Skalverei, transforming into the full Vollstandig form that he used against Ichigo. Apparently, Renji is still pulling his punches a bit according to Uryu, and begins to attack Renji again with even more feathers, and activates the ability Federzwinger.

Federzwinger seems to be a more advanced version of Uryu's Sprenger attack, only instead of Reishi Rods, the floating feathers combine into five glowing rods that trap Renji in a cage-like formation before stabbing him with energy spikes. Uryu explains that Federzwinger will drain everything within its walls, even citing Shikai and Bankai as losing their power. I'm... not entirely sure if I'm supposed to take this literally and Uryu is attempting a Bankai-steal, or if it's just Uryu being dramatic about Renji losing power.

Federzwinger concludes and explodes, dropping Renji with his zanpakuto reverted to its sealed state. But Renji gets pissed at Uryu, asking him what he really knows about Bankai. As Uryu calmly pulls a regular bow and arrow and targets Renji's chest, Renji gives one last defiant speech, noting that his Bankai is not called 'twin kings' for nothing. A spectral version of the baboon arm squelches out of Renji's own hand, and I'm not sure what this implies -- I guess it's a version of 'the sword is me' lesson that Ichigo also learned in the Soul Palace? Renji fires off a version of his Hihio Zabimaru's finisher attack, Hikotsu Taiho...

...But Uryu's arrow cuts through the Hikotsu Taiho and punches a hole through Renji's chest, causing the vice-captain to collapse. 

Uryu then walks up to Renji and lists three reasons why he lost -- he was unconsciously holding back; he didn't know about Uryu's new powers... and he's a Shinigami that Uryu hates. 

Again, that is really cool. In the manga, as I keep complaining Uryu does nothing but lurk around in the background and has ominous expressions and one or two lines here and there, and shot the floor under Ichigo once. Renji, after defeating Mask, also does nothing but run with the rest of the group, maybe clashing against Gerard for a couple of panels. We never really saw what else his Bankai could do! But giving the two a confrontation is a very unexpected move by the anime. It really is a good moment for Uryu in particular, and it really does highlight how he might be going too far with his infiltration, especially with how much he's literally hurting his friends. Again, a great addition and the fight itself is really spectacular. Really love how dynamic So'o Zabimaru is, and being able to see what both Uryu's Vollstandig and Renji's Bankai could do is just great. 

Random Notes:
  • At some point in this episode, there is a brief, non-voiced shot of Haschwalth standing in front of a giant circular energy sphere. This shot was shown in many of the trailers, and most hardcore Bleach fans just assumed that this was the anime's take on the Gate of the Sun. This episode is called the Gate of the Sun, but that most certainly is not the same Gate of the Sun that the other Schutzstaffle were using! So what is that? That thing doesn't seem to tie into anything that we know of in the source material, so I wonder if we're getting a bit more to either the Haschwalth/Bazz-B or Haschwalth/Uryu fights.
    • Yes, the Gates of the Sun were never, ever shown in the manga. People mention them a bit but we never saw any of them.
  • Rather interestingly, after being mostly ignored after the first invasion, Bazz-B, Liltotto and Giselle make use of Shadows to move around. I'm actually not sure if this would still work since the original concept was that the Shadows of the Seireitei was what allowed them to appear in the Soul Society from the shadowy parallel dimension. Looks cool, though!
  • I am slightly disappointed that the scene of the Schutzstaffel hanging out in lounge chairs was removed. It admittedly felt a bit out of place, but it was really funny. 
  • The anime adds a little line saying how Ichigo's team can't contact their other allies with Soul Pagers due to the disruption of the Reishi. A very nice little inclusion to handwave their behaviour.
  • Gerard is slightly nicer in this anime adaptation. In the source material, he actually accuses the other Qiuncies of tricking him into taking a direction without enemies to screw with him. 
  • I love that Kubo decides to make the pun of the "Gift Balls" because the German word for poison is actually 'gift'. (The German word for 'gift' is 'geschenk'). 
  • The anime -- and notably, the earlier cour 2 which cut a fair amount of unnecessary scenes -- did keep Shuhei's Bankai training with Kensei and Mashiro. So while they also kept Shuhei being shot by Lille, is it a possibility that we're going to see Fushi no Kojyo being activated to keep him alive and kicking at some point down the line? 
  • Interestingly, Uryu doesn't ever show a halo when he's in his Vollstandig, with or without Sklaverai. 
  • The idea of shed monkey fur being used as a conduit for combat magic is, of course, a nod to Sun Wukong being able to rip off his hair and blow on it, turning the hair into facsimiles of himself. 
  • The next couple of episodes will be faithful adaptations of source material fights, so hopefully they will take less time for me to produce!

Tuesday, 10 December 2024

Agatha All Along S01E07 Review: Death Thirteen

Agatha All Along, Season 1, Episode 7: Death's Hand in Mine


So yeah, this is a pretty interesting episode. I've talked about how the first half of the series has been quite happy to pretend that it's a typical "focus on one character per episode" type of ensemble show, and we've got focus episodes for some of the newly-introduced characters. Alice had a fair bit of intrigue intrinsically thanks to her background, but she was also dealt with very quickly once the narrative gave her focus. Jennifer... she sticks around and she gets comedic moments, but ultimately I don't think we got quite enough out of her for me to really care about her that much. With Agatha, Billy and Rio being obviously set up for something larger for the two-part climax, this leaves the divination witch Lilia Calderu as the one that hasn't got a trial before Billy "kills" her two episodes ago. 

Of course, that's not the end for either Lilia or Jennifer, who was swamped alongside her. The main plot is still about the coven going through the Witches' Road, of course, and the next trial finds Billy and Agatha transported to a tarot reading table while swords fall down from the ceiling all around them if they make the wrong reading. And since Agatha shares my worldview that you can fortune-tell anything by drawing vague connections from what a card is supposed to mean and experiences in your life, the Road... doesn't appreciate that too much. 

(Oh yeah, this episode's costuming theme is all about fictional witches, which is probably the costume changes in this show that actually made me giggle the most)

I would also like to note that this episode is told in a rather non-chronological order. It's not hard to follow, but it is a nice showcase of just how Lilia's world works. She isn't just a divination witch, but she's also constantly traveling through time due to... some reasons? It doesn't really matter, but we have seen Lilia actually zone out and say cryptic shit all throughout the series. Both the cast and the audience probably handwaved it as her just being a weird fortune-teller, but it's actually Lilia traveling back through time briefly. We see Lilia as she jumps back even all the way to her youth, meeting her teacher and discussing about the nature of her power. We get to see a confused Lilia in the present day walking through an underground corridor with Jen, who nonchalantly notes that when Lilia zoned out a couple minutes ago, she had explained a bunch of stuff... and we actually get to see this exchange happen later on. 

The episode was also very thick at hanging a figurative narrative knife over Lilia's head, with her noting that the 'end is near'... of course, Jen thinks she means the Road, but it's pretty clear that Lilia's not making out of the episode alive. We get some nice flashbacks that helps to ground things, removed from all the chaos and bluster of the Witches' Road, every time Lilia is transported to centuries past when she's supposed to be learning divination of tea leaves from her Maestra, which I thought was a nice decision to give us something removed from the Witches' Road saga.

I don't want to tear down every single scene since that would also involve me going back to the past 6 episodes to point out all the moments that Lilia's spoken to the cast from the future, but it definitely is pretty smartly done and foreshadowed quite well. (The coolest -- and most tragic -- is having Lilia's "Alice, don't try to save Agatha" advice be cut up in two halves that the words that Lilia says right before Alice's death ends up just being the last four).

The actual narration and progression of the story is essentially "Agatha and Billy get into trouble, Lilia and Jen shows up, Lilia does a reading and realizes some things about herself, Lilia then sacrifices herself to take down the bad guys". A nice bit of plot progression, but it would've been bland without the character work they did for ol' Lilia.

In addition to all the continuity nods, and the explanation for all the times Lilia randomly blurts out Tarot readings throughout the past six episodes, we also get a lot of themes about Lilia falling through the void, and she also describes her experiences unbound in time as something similar. It's a nice metaphorical, thematic visualization of how she views her power and her life, but also a nice foreshadowing of what happens in the future... and the past.

As the episode reaches its climax and Lilia travels through time and does her readings of her journey over and over again, Lilia pulls out the 'Death' card. No ominous tarot reading is ever complete without Death showing his face! Or rather, her face. Lilia travels back through time to the moment when she and Jen wakes up after being swamped, to see Rio hovering ominously in the distance... with her face transformed into a skull. Which... yes, Rio is Death. The literal, cosmical, magical manifestation of Death, a character that is quite prominent in the Marvel comics and was adapted out of that whole Thanos duology. I guess I kind of wanted more gravitas to this revelation since Rio with skull makeup doesn't quite hit as hard as I felt it should? It is admittedly nice to give some context to Rio beyond "Agatha's psycho ex". 

Which also kind of sets up Rio as the final antagonist of the show. Well, what about the previous antagonists that have been chasing our heroes all through this? Lilia pushes her three friends out as she locks the door behind them, and then with a declaration of "I loved being a witch", she spins the Tower card upside-down. Disaster, destruction, sudden upheaval. As the Salem Seven enters the tower, it gets spun around alongside the card. Which I actually thought was a cute way to acknowledge how the orientation of cards in a Tarot reading is important. The room flips upside down, impaling the Salem Seven on the swords. Lilia falls -- which gives us the falling scenes from previous parts of the episode -- and dies, a life full and content .

And... I do think this is my favourite episode of Agatha All Along, even having watched all the way to the end. I do feel like the show isn't quite as well-constructed as some of its most ardent fans claim it is -- and the Salem Seven's execution (and even inclusion?) is a huge proof of that. Another is Rio's build-up as Death, and yet another is Jennifer in general. But Lilia's story, and how it was literally interwoven into the narrative of the previous six episodes? That was really well done, and this is a very powerful episode and a great sendoff for her. 

Marvel Easter Eggs Corner:
  • In the Marvel comics, Death personified as a female figure is a recurring cosmic entity, most often associated with Thanos and Deadpool, both of whom are enamoured with her.
    • It seems like in this show has basically replaced adapted parts of Thanos being in an unhealthy relationship with Death (depending on the writer it goes either way) and transplanted it to Agatha. 
  • The song "Time in a Bottle" by Jim Croce was previously used in a different Marvel project, X-Men: Days of Future's Past, with Quicksilver's iconic super-speed sequence. Whether on purpose or not, Evan Peters reprises his role as Ralph Bohner/Fake Quicksilver last episode.
  • Not exactly Marvel, but Marvel-adjacent since Disney owns them now, but Billy is dressed up as Sleeping Beauty's Maleficent and Jen as the Evil Queen's hag form from Snow White. Meanwhile, Agatha is dressed up as the Wicked Witch of the West from Wizard of Oz and Lilia as the good witch Glinda. 

Sunday, 8 December 2024

One Piece 1133 Review: I Want To Live

One Piece, Chapter 1133: Praise Me


This is going to be a bit different than my normal One Piece reviews, where I tend to break down more or less chronologically what happens in the chapter. Not this time. On paper, 'plot-wise', not a lot happened here. People meet other people, Robin gets reunited with Saul. That's it. 

But in a post-timeskip world where a lot of the emotional punches -- particularly to the Straw Hats -- have been very muted, I really appreciate that Oda is giving Nico Robin one full chapter just revolving around her. It really is a moment I saw coming, but the way it's executed -- with Oda very cleverly bringing in some aspects of Robin's history and backstory in the manga we've read years and years ago. History is, indeed, as the archaeologist would say, very important here in contextualizing what would otherwise just be two people meeting each other. Knowing what we know of Robin's character, of her regular unwillingness to be vulnerable, of her struggles, of everything that has happened in Enies' Lobby... those are what builds up and makes chapter 1133 actually a powerful chapter. 

And this also makes me excited to ese other payoffs, since Oda proves that he can deliver these emotional moments post-timeskip for the main characters. One of the worries I've had was always that while the chapters post-timeskip have been emotional, they've mostly been revolving around other non-Straw-Hats. Shirahoshi, Law, Momonosuke, Bonney and Kuma... all great stories, but ultimately in many of these arcs, a lot of the titular Straw Hats don't actually get much development (with the exception of Sanji in Whole Cake Island). This makes me super excited for the inevitable Usopp moment in the future!

Anyway, we start this off with some flashbacks of Robin's terrible childhood, but seen from the perspectives of other people. That asshole Spandine spreading misinformation, and the old 'kindly' couple who took Robin in and all that. Again, while the original version of this flashback focused a bit more on Robin's panic as she runs around, this one really hammers home how oppressively world-changing the misinformation was. How literally everyone hated Robin, the falsehoods that are spread around to justify hunting and murdering an 8-year-old "Devil Child"...

Leading to a surprisingly dark moment with Robin on the edge of a cliff, contemplating suicide. It's not surprising that this was something that would unfortunately befall her, especially with what she's been through, but it's also really sad to see drawn on page as well. Only the memories of Olvia and Saul get Robin to stop actually making the fatal plunge. "LIVE! ROBIN!"

Another very sad scene was Robin looking around in some books, and seeing a geography book, she discovers that Ohara has been expunged from all books. She doodles in Ohara with a pen, right before someone recognizes her and forces her to run. Everyone around her tells her to die, that she shouldn't live, and the only recourse in her life is to run. It's so hard for her to even live. 

Again, it's pretty heartwrenching and while we do know Robin is in a much better spot (after going through hell and back in Water Seven and Enies' Lobby... which, by the way, is the biggest 'fuck no' reason to the idea of Rob Lucci joining the Straw Hat Grand Fleet or whatever) but the flashbacks really does help to hammer home just how much Saul -- no, not even Saul, but the memory of Saul -- is important to Robin. 

Anyway, some other stuff I'll cover below happens in the present day. The Straw Hats meet the New Giant Pirates, and we get a lot of introductions and whatnot. But Robin tries to excuse herself to go and meet Saul. And... it's perhaps a bit of an understated scene, but the entire Straw Hat crew goes with her. I love that she's still in this "I won't trouble anyone" mentality but the Straw Hats are her goddamn family and Luffy in particular has a very nice line about how he has to greet someone who took care of one of his nakama properly.

He turned down a feast for that. Luffy's an airhead, but sometimes he remembers his priorities. 

They arrive at the Warrior Springs, and we get a fun moment where Luffy wants to just charge in and drag Saul to the party... but Nami literally wrestles him down to the ground. God bless these idiots. 

And, of course, we get the cliffhanger from a couple chapters back. Oh no! Mr. Saul has fallen down and he can't get up! The Straw Hats all yell at this as much as the fandom did, but of course it's nothing serious. Of course Oda isn't the type of guy who'd torpedo a moment like this just out of the sake of 'subverting expectations'.

But Robin knows what's up. She sees Saul collapsed on the beach, and she just walks up while laughing. In some perfectly paralleled panels with her original meeting with Saul, Robin walks up to the "fallen" giant on the beach. Saul screams at Robin in a mimicry of their first appearance, and turns out that Saul 'fell' because he's such a dork that he's trying to recreate their first meeting. 

And it's so dorky. We get a little comparison of little Robin's deadpan reaction back then and the grown woman that she is now.

And we get the reunion. It starts off pretty light-hearted as Saul apologizes for her little gag, before lifting Robin up and saying that she looks so much like Olvia. Did anyone ever tell Robin that? Everyone who knew Olvia would've been dead (or, in Saul's case, presumed dead) by the time Robin grew up. It's a nice, understated moment. 

They discuss a bit about Vegapunk's message and Ohara's legacy. We get a bit of a discussion of that, and a bit of a discussion on how Saul survived (the ice attack melted from the Buster Call flames, and through some means Saul made his way to Elbaf). Saul then makes a brief rant about how the world said so much awful things about Robin... but Robin just gives a downcast smile before beaming at him with an open grin, telling Saul not to focus on 'dark stuff' and ask Saul if he will praise her for being alive.

Again, this starts off a bit light-hearted and happy, with Saul hugging Robin (as much as a giant can), laughing and yelling about how Robin was a god damned survivor who stayed alive for 22 years, to survive to reunite with Saul. We get a brief flashback to a crying child Robin. "Why am I the only one who has to live?" "I want to die." Contrasted, of course, against Robin's immortal line at the climax of Enies' Lobby. 

This was a child who was crushed by the world. Driven to suicide, driven to think that no one in the world wanted her. Driven to think that the best way to solve a problem is to let herself die so the few people she cared about in the world would live. Driven off by every person she met, who sold her out. Driven only by the dead phantoms of the past, pursued by those who would want her dead for sins not of her own doing. Driven by the faint hope that maybe one day she'll meet someone who would be her family. 

And she found that family. After more than two decades of running, she found that family. That family said "fuck the world, come with us". And she finally decided that yes, it's okay, this one time, to be selfish enough to say something that everyone else takes for granted -- "I want to live". 

And Robin isn't normally an emotional character. She's a lot more subtle... which she displays throughout all of her meting with Saul earlier. All the slight smiles, the ufufufu giggling, the cute haircut a couple of chapters back... and after Saul yells out all of this, Robin starts ugly crying. This is one of the few times where Robin allows the emotional dam within herself to rupture and for her to acknowledge the gigantic mountain of hurt and suffering that's building up within her... something that she couldn't acknowledge before else it would crush her. 

She's crying. Saul's crying. Most of the Straw Hats are crying. Luffy's happy for them.

These emotional moments with the main core characters have been a bit more rare since I've started reading One Piece. But this was a great chapter. 

Until then, dereshishishishi to all of you. 

Random Notes:
  • Yamato Cover Story: The antagonist is revealed to be... Holdem, a.k.a. "one-shot by Red Hawk" guy. Okay? I was expecting one of the Tobi-roppo or Jack or someone. This isn't the most excitement-inducing character, but I suppose the cover story is finally going somewhere.
  • Some other non-Robin related stuff that happens in this chapter, because I'm glazing over it:
    • We see a 'Svalr', which is a rowboat that can fly using island clouds on the tip of their oars. Lilith identifies it as a mixture of technologies.
    • All the Straw Hats and New Giant Pirates reunite, and Rodo is crucified. God bless you, Gerd and Goldberg. I actually wouldn't mind it if Rodo actually gets seriously kicked out of the New Giant Pirates, and Hajrudin seems to be already halfway there with the gag of saying that his crew is four-man strong instead of five. 
    • Gerd noting that something that made the Straw Hats super famous was that they took down Big Mom. Gerd also acknowledges that in the past, she and Big Mom used to be friends.
    • Some nice world-building around the Owl Library and the Warrior Springs about how they are formed and stuff. Pretty great D&D-style stuff. 
  • That said, while One Piece nails the emotional side of things, I do believe that in terms of logical cohesion there are a lot of holes in Saul's situation. While I guess the whole "Saul is faking his death" thing is a legitimate enough issue why the world thinks he's dead, but I'm really not sure why he hasn't tried to contact Robin and bring her to Elbaf in the intervening 22 years. At least send some young giants out to talk to her or something! But I guess Robin is just that good at hiding. 
  • Really love the little moment where Nami complements Robin's hair and goes 'ah, of course you will do this'. Little moments like this. More of these little moments of the Straw Hats interacting, please and thank you. 
  • Also, that "gotta greet someone who took care of (his) crewmates properly" is totally a Shanks thing, isn't it?
  • Among the Straw Hats, Zoro and Jinbe join Luffy in not crying and just watching in silence .I do really like that Oda spends time trying to think what everyone's reactions would be in this situation -- even among those that are crying, the difference between Usopp and Franky's ugly crying to Sanji and Nami trying to cover their faces because they're the type to think of not ruining the moment is a nice character touch. 
  • It really makes me wonder if Franky not getting anything in Egghead is because Oda is saving moments for each Straw Hat at some point in the future? A big character moment? Some of them would be obvious (Brook meeting Laboon; Zoro and Mihawk; Usopp at some point in Elbaf) but I do wonder how it would be for some of them. Is Nami going to meet Arlong? Is Franky going to have some huge moment with Pluton? What about Chopper, or Jinbe, or Sanji? 
  • Robin's backstory with Saul was published almost 20 years ago. Not quite 22, but still!

Friday, 6 December 2024

Bleach TYBW E32 Review: cAll forth the twilight, mirokumAru

Bleach, Thousand-Year Blood War, Episode 32: The Holy Newborn


This forms the second part of the two-parter connective tissue after the Death of the Soul King action-packed series of episodes (which was even more action packed with two additional Ichigo battle episodes in the anime) and the upcoming final showdown of the Shinigami against the Schutzstaffel. And while it is kind of slow to have two such episodes back-to-back, it is way better than how it was done in the manga where, as I mentioned in the previous episode, the entire sequence of trying to create the gate to access the Soul King's Palace happens and fails so many times in scenes intercut with Juhabach killing the Soul King. This rearrangement (in addition to the aforementioned new fight scenes) lets that Juhabach/Soul King scene play off in a much more focused and epic way, while the inherently less-interesting "what are the B-team doing" stories are all clumped together to flow in a way that makes it feel more natural. 

One major change is that this is where the reiatsu-absorbing orbs come in. In the manga, Urahara has been handing these out since before Ukitake's sacrifice, before the Soul King's death, and most certainly a long time before anything that happens in this episode. Here, it's something that's done after a major reassembly of the entire Gotei 13 and a speech about the turnaround fight from Kyoraku. The whole scene flows a lot better, scenes are more snappy, and it even ties to what's going to happen next.

The anime also makes a slight change to how Juhabach creates Wahrwelt. In the manga, he apparently just teleports the buildings from where the Vandenreich empire is fused to the Seireitei into the Soul Palace... which, by the way, is something I never realized. I've always thought that Juhabach created Wahrwelt in the Soul Palace! In the anime, we see the giant goopy tendrils trail down from the heavens to lift up the Vandenreich's buildings into the sky. It's another display of power from Juhabach, and one that looks just visually spectacular and intimidating. 

Up above, with team Ichigo, we get a series of faithfully-adapted scenes from the manga. Grimmjow shows up and does a pretty cool sword-slash shockwave to greet Ichigo. Any potential fight is interrupted with surprise boobs as Neliel leaps in to hug Ichigo, one-shotting Grimmjow with her bosom mid-leap. Nel gives some exposition about how during the offscreen Hueco Mundo scenes, Urahara made a bracelet to deal with Nel's child form, and now she can stay in her adult form indefinitely. We get the comedic moment from the manga delightfully retained, where Orihime is extremely flustered at Nel's arrival and Chad makes a supportive wingman comment about Urahara making unnecessary things. Orihime's reaction to this is funny. 

Again, it's nice to see these characters again after having them be out of the loop for quite a while now. Grimmjow and Nel get into a bit of a piss-fight, and I do like that Nel can jump straight into a serious voice when dealing with anything that is not Ichigo. There's a fun little argument about the Espada numbers, but again, any fight between allies is interrupted as two more former enemies show up -- the Xcution members Riruka Dokugamine and Yukio Hans Vorarlberna. 

Since this is probably the best place to talk about it, I would like to say that I really disliked Xcution when I first read through the manga -- with the best part of the Xcution arc for me being the ending when the shinigami show up to show their overwhelming strength and tactics over the Xcution assholes. I've since had a much greater appreciation for the arc, particularly the 'back to basics' urban fantasy vibe that the Xcution arc returned us to, and I appreciate Tsukishima and Ginjo as antagonists if not quite as well-developed characters. So having at least some of them show up for the end is quite nice, I feel, even if Riruka and Yukio are essentially just here as a cosmic taxi service. 

Ichigo is absolutely bamboozled by everything that's going on, and I like the deadpan replies from Chad and Orihime, who already knew that the Arrancar and Fullbringers are working with them. Ichigo's utter "EXPLAIN! EVERYTHING!" frustration and the others telling him that they've been in life-and-death situations throughout the entire TYBW storyline. 

We then have Yukio (who's just so tired of this whole shit) take out his PSP (I love his PSP) and pull up an explanation about the way that they are essentially combining the Garganta, his "Invaders Must Die" powers, Riruka's "Dollhouse" powers and the little pockets of space called the Kyogoku/Valley of Screams in order to allow them to move around. It's a lot of technical stuff that existed in the manga, and after the first cour really trimmed down Mayuri's world-building exposition about Bankai, it is actually nice to see them talk a bit more about this -- which I suppose is also necessary to show why both Riruka and Yukio needed to be there.

More interestingly, the anime kept around the mentions about the "Valley of Screams". Which I'll elaborate a bit on, since I don't really feel about typing out Yukio's whole exposition. The Valley of Screams as a concept are something introduced in the first Bleach movie, "Memories of Nobody". I'd say that it's probably the best out of the four theatrical Bleach movies and probably the only one you can slot into a place in the manga continuity considering the fact that everyone in that movie either fades away or dies. The manga had the references to not just the Valley of Screams, but also a line where Ichigo notes that he's been in a Valley of Screams. These lines are retained in the anime, and even the eyecatcher has a scarf with maple leaves falling down around it -- which are both heavily associated with the movie-original character Senna. So the anime, which hasn't been a stranger to cutting out inconsistencies in their adaptation, actually is reinforcing the Memories of Nobody tie-in. That's interesting! 

Anyway, after all of the world-building exposition, we cut to the shinigami below. The gate's not forming properly, and we get a discussion lifted from another part of the manga where they acknowledge Ukitake's immense store of reiatsu that they need but have lost access to. It a bit awkward since in the manga Ukitake was participating in this reiatsu-orb activity before the Mimihagi ritual, but it's nice that it's acknowledged regardless. We get a nice moment as Lisa calms down Nanao as she is panicking, while the rest of the Visored show up in their shinigami uniforms. It's at this point that Mayuri pulls out the Reiatsu Amplification Device (tm), which he has all along just like in the manga... but here, the placement and the speed of the orb-charging scenes means that Mayuri looks less like an idiot since in the anime's version of events, Mayuri just lets them try for a bit before pulling it out, instead of pulling it out after almost 10 chapters of trials and failures. Narratively speaking, it also flows better in general, where this ends up feeling like Mayuri's contribution to the process that doesn't really diminish Urahara, Aizen and Ukitake's moments. 

Back in the Invaders-Must-Die Garganta Elevator, Yoruichi explains their assassination plan. We get a rather unintentionally hilarious scene as Chad makes a comment that Ichigo needs to focus on Juhabach because they have a 'decent understanding' of the Elite Guard's powers. No you fucking don't, Chad. The best you could tell is Pernida contorting limbs, and as the Pernida/Mayuri fight will show, that's a mere fraction of that Pernida can do.

There's some nice moments with Riruka and Grimmjow in particular here. With her 'tough love', Riruka snaps Orihime of a bit of a depressive funk (by slapping her with her hoodie bird wings). Ichigo and Grimmjow also get a bit of a conversation, with Grimmjow making it clear that his priority is to make sure he and Ichigo have a place to fight in, although he's most likely just acting a bit tsundere.

In the Soul Palace, Juhabach assumes his full form (again, despite the ending of episode 30) and liquid darkness flows out of the Soul King's chamber. And throughout these scenes, good old Askin Nakk le Vaar is our POV guy as he is royally unnerved by Juhabach's upper head being covered by roiling eyeballs. Even when Haschwalth tells Askin to calm down, Askin gets a hilarious internal reaction of wondering what is wrong with Haschwalth. Juhabach actually responds to Askin, but it's essentially in the vein of 'oh well, you'll get used to me in time. Juhabach then starts forming Wahrwelt with the floating rubble, and poor Askin is just jumping around and scrabbling as he tries to hold on to the collapsing rubble. 

By the way, Askin, two episodes ago you were making fun of Ganju about how Sternritter have wings and can fly. Forgot about that, did you? Haha! 

As Wahrwelt is properly formed, we get a badsas scene as Juhabach lets his power flow through the transformed Soul Palace, which, thanks to the five floating mini-palaces, transforms into a giant glowing Quincy five-pointed star. The Sternritter gather around again, and, interestingly, Juhabach still addresses Haschwalth as his 'first son'. That was always a plot point that kind of went nowhere in the manga, so I wonder if we'll get something to address it. 

Team Ichigo arrives at their destination, supposedly teleporting to a marking nail that Yoruichi set down during the battle before the Soul King. We get a fun little interaction between Yukio and Ganju, the latter incensed that the former isn't helping them to fight. But realistically, it kind of makes sense that the Fullbringers are kind of out of their depth in terms of power level, and with their power sets it does make more sense to keep them around as support. We also get the Ichigo/Riruka scene here, where Ichigo thanks Riruka for her sacrifice since using Dollhouse on something as uncute as the Valley of Screams is likely very taxing on her. Again, nice moments all around, and Ganju reaffirms that Ichigo has 'always been like this'.    

Both Team Urahara and Team Ichigo arrive on what's supposed to be the Soul Palace at the same time (though not on the same place), but we get a nice, drawn-out scene as they look surprised at the terrain around them. It's depressing, gloomy Vandenreich buildings drenched in a purplish-pink glow. Their coordinates are right, and Yoruichi even finds her stake displaced on the ground. Urahara explains what's happened to the stunned crowd, and I do like that Wahrwelt's existence ends up being given some time to breathe.

In their respective groups, Yoruichi and Yushiro detect each other's reiatsu. Yoruichi and Ichigo get into a bit of a comedic moment over this internal revelation, while Yushiro tries to fly towards his sister... only to almost fall to his death if not for Renji's intervention. We get the revelation that the reishi in Wahrwelt has been manipulated by the Quincies, who has taken contrl of the normally-dense reishi i the Soul Palace. In theory, this means that no one but the Quincies can fly, but... I'm 100% sure that this will cease to matter once the fights go underway. 

After some debriefing about what they need to do (including a mention from Kyoraku about installing a new Soul King, if necessary -- a plot point that was heavily teased in the manga but never got a payoff until the pseudo-canon novels). The episode ends with Juhabach's castle, Silbern, rising in the distance, taunting them like a video game final dungeon. Juhabach sits on his throne while his Schutzstaffel kneel before him, reporting of the shinigami intruding upon their domain. Juhabach closes down the episode with a talk about how this is the foundation of his one and true world, and how the Sternritter now have to go and kill the things in the way of their final goal. 

Overall, it's... it's, again, mostly connective tissue. Even in my recap/review here, I think I spend as much time praising the comedy and noting some of the more 'meta' observations like the Valley of Screams or the restructuring more than anything. It works well, though, and 31 and 32 are a nice bit for us to breathe before the battles in Wahrwelt start happening in the next episode. I do really like them stretching the creation of Wahrwelt for what it's worth at the final couple of minutes in this episode, which gives the final battleground a sense of gravitas which I don't remember feeling when I read it in the manga. 

Random Notes:
  • A cut comedic scene involves Ichigo and friends trying to mentally imagine what Yoruichi's brother looks like, first imagining him as being muscular, before imagining a cat with a sword. 
  • Not that I'm expecting him to show up, but one major absentee in the "all the Shinigami gather together" is Iba and doggy!Komamura. With the final episode of cour 2 giving them some additional (albeit non-speaking scenes), it's a bit of a surprise that they don't at least make a cameo appearance in the background even if they don't go up to the Soul King's Palace.
  • Mashiro Kuna, a.k.a. the Visored Kubo forgot, is explicitly shown going up to Wahrwelt with the others! She's in the massive group shot of captains and vice-captains that assemble behind Kyoraku! Doubtful that she'll do much, but at least she's there!
  • Kon just kind of disappears after the end of the last episode, huh? I kinda wished the anime at least kept him around in the background.
  • A nice little detail with the bunch of lesser shinigami showing up is that people like Yuki and Shino (who's more junior) or Renji (who's notably poor in Kido) have to use two hands to charge the reiatsu orbs, whereas the more experienced captains, vice-captains (and Sternritter) can do it with one.
  • Also a nice little added scene that I forgot to mention above is Kyoraku briefly saying some words to Ukitake before his team goes through the door. 
  • I've always thought that adult Nel's 'bodysuit' was an anime censorship thing, and that the manga version 'just' has the bone bikini and the fur collar/gloves, but the bodysuit's still retained for the TYBW anime. Huh! 
  • I love Yukio and his PSP. It just really speaks of the time that Bleach was originally written, huh? People have all this new-fangled mobile phone gaming now! We used to have PSP's and GBA's and we liked those!
  • I also really like Yukio's slightly-irritated but ultimately-indifferent reaction to Yoruichi describing "Invaders Must Die" as being an electricity-manipulating power. He knows that's an oversimplification of his powers, but fuck it, he's too tired to complain. Same, Yukio. Same.
  • The way Pernida grabs on to the rubble by undulating his head is... interesting, although if you don't know what's under that hood it'll look even more bizarre than Pernida already is. 
  • The animation gets an inexplicable bump during the Ichigo and Riruka scene, which is a bit jarring considering some of the complaints about Aizen's expression in the past couple of episodes being off-model in some shots. 
  • Soi Fon's bandages just utterly disappear the moment she walks through the gate of the sun. Hopefully those are the only things that disappear, and Soi Fon herself doesn't pull off the same disappearing act that her manga counterpart did.