One Piece, Chapter 1191: There's Still Loki
Picking up from where last chapter left off, Luffy is still struggling to get back up after his injury of being pierced multiple times by Imu's royal swords. I will straight up note that I'm not a big fan of just how quick Luffy appears to recover in this chapter -- while 1190 does have Scopper Gaban lay it on to Luffy about his lack of taking things seriously, I did wish for something more akin to the Sabaody or Marineford 'lessons'. Even if it's not quite as tragic as those two pre-timeskip stuff, I really didn't like it that Luffy essentially bounces back with some strange Gear Fifth bullshittery in this one. It's not as bad as some of the Wano parts, but I really hope this chapter is an anomaly and we get some character development for Luffy in the Elbaf arc.

Luffy, at least, acknowledges that his wounds are severe enough that he would be in big trouble if he gets out of Gear Fifth at any point. There's a nice bit where Luffy apologizes to Gaban for 'taking the hit', only for Gaban to get pissed off at Luffy for thinking that -- he's just protecting Elbaf. Gaban wraps up his amputated arm, and tells Luffy that Imu is basically 'god'.
We get shots of random animals being knocked out by Imu's Conqueror's Haki. Imu himself is lying on his back, not entirely unscathed from Gaban's Gate of God attack, and reflects that he should have eliminated all of Roger's crew in God Valley alongside Rocks. Imu then proceeds to transform -- into what I view as a Dark Souls style 'second phase'. His horns are larger and more ram-like, the placement of his tattoos have changed, and his arms are fully black (Armament Haki?). The general look is a more heavyset, more bulky form, and the large black wings does really make him look a lot more like a Lunarian. Imu is also seemingly larger than before, although it really is hard to tell -- One Piece has never been the best with scale.
I do like this form a bit less than the original one, but I feel like this is the case with most villains that go through forms -- not many people care for Freeza or Cell's middle forms, after all.
There's a brief cutaway to Robin, Chopper and Saul talking to Biblo. As what we've expected, they do want to get Chopper to talk to the mysterious ancient owl, and Biblo does go 'hoot hoot hoot'... but while Chopper does have a reaction, we as the readers don't get to learn this. Okay, sure.
We cut back to Imu in his new form attacking the wounded Luffy and Gaban. Imu and Gaban trade some barbs, including a hilarious bit where Gaban notes that he would applaud Imu, but, y'know, he's only got one arm left. Imu tells Luffy to get his crew and flee Elbaf, but Luffy doesn't want to do that, outmatched or not.
I do think that unless we're going to highlight the 'tragedy' thing, with Gaban and potentially more of the giants dying, we won't be leaving Elbaf the way we escaped Egghead... Luffy is invested in the wellbeing of the people of Elbaf, and even if they don't get a full victory, I feel like the way to end this arc would have to be the implied timer on Imu.
Luffy and Gaban, both in not much of a shape to block another attack from Imu, brace for impact... and motherfucking HAJRUDIN of all people comes in with Gungnir to punch Imu the fuck away.
God bless Hajrudin. He has been theoretically one of the most important characters in this arc, being a member of the Straw Hat Grand Fleet, and the son of a king... but from a fighting standpoint, we need to remember that Hajrudin was beaten effortlessly by a Gear Second Luffy, and had to struggle to take out even one of Doflamingo's lesser minions.
But god damn it, with all of the story we've been told via Loki, can you blame the guy for trying? He just comes in with his strongest move Gungnir, and while the physical blast is impressive, I don't get the sense that Imu is injured -- just waylaid unexpectedly. And even then, Hajrudin had to block Imu's black flame-bomb attack; his arm-shield shattering in the process.
As Imu recovers, Gaban tells Hajrudin to get Luffy away, since "there's no way to win". Luffy adamantly refuses, with some bullshit handwave about 'eating a lot' before coming here. Hajrudin protects Luffy and Gaban from another barrage of bombs. Hajrudin is prepared to die for Elbaf, noting that "if I die... there's still Loki!"
It's a nice little mini-arc going in the background of all this madness, but the Hajrudin/Loki mutual respect is slowly growing over the background. And just in cue, Loki comes in to help his big brother. That is cool! A bit less cool (and inexplicable, judging by Gaban's reaction) is Luffy swelling up and going "I'm all better too!". He still does look a bit wounded so I'm not calling full bullshit yet, but I am worried about the deflating tension from this battle when the last couple of chapters built up Imu's threat to Luffy specifically quite well.
Loki, Hajrudin and Luffy deals a triple-combo Gokoku Sovereignty attack; the same one that Gerd, Rodo and Goldberg did earlier in the arc. Cool moment, but I felt like this really should be a Loki and Hajrudin moment and we didn't need Luffy butting into the brothers' attack. But oh well. Again, it's a nice payoff to the two princes' storyline, and I'm a fan of it being at least tied up now.
It's a bit annoying that I'm coming back to review single chapters on what I think is the weakest chapter in this Imu battle, but it is admittedly a bit early to be going on a proverbial witch-hunt when it's just a quick single chapter. We'll see if we continue this fight next chapter, or if we'll cut away to the Zoro or Sanji fights -- which has remained conspicuously absent. I wouldn't mind it if we just have some 'hold the line' bit for the wounded group here holding Imu off (well, three are wounded, while Hajrudin's just outclassed).
Random Notes:
- Single chapter review this time around, because I'm a bit freer this week. Not sure if this is going to keep happening, and depending on my schedule I may go back to 3-5 chapters in a go.
- The strange panda and wolf-bunny monster, as with all Elbafian wildlife, were creatures that first debuted in One Piece: Strong World.
- Some people are trying to map Imu's current forms to the three Zoan forms... but I feel that's not what the story is going for. Luffy, after all, is also a 'god Zoan' and his forms and gears are all over the place compared to the human/beast/hybrid dichotomy.
- Since we do have some time, I would like to note that we did get a significant number of Imu's nineteen blades (he's missing Lily's blade) named, and most of them refer to a legendary weapon or some kind of religious meaning:
- Stigma is a term that means a 'brand' from Greco-Roman culture, usually a brand or tattoo to mark a status of disgrace. However, due to Christianity, the term 'stigma' or 'stigmata' has since been associated with the crucifixion wounds of Jesus Christ; and wounds that appear in similar places reported in some devout followers.
- Longinus, or rather the 'Spear of Longinus', is taken from extended Christianity mythos. It is stated that the soldier that pierced Jesus Christ's side with his spear was named Longinus, and the spear, coated with the blood of Christ, was transformed into a holy lance -- with many various relics over the Middle Ages being claimed to be the holy lance that allowed whoever held it to have the right to rule.
- Nemesis is the Greek goddess of divine retribution. While often mistranslated by modern interpretations as a mere 'goddess of revenge', the original Nemesis is tasked with meting out punishments specifically to mortals that show pride and hubris before gods.
- Fragarach, Blade of the Sea God, is a magical sword from Irish mythology that belonged to the sea god ManannĂ¡n mac Lir, which can cause wounds that do not heal, and force people to tell the truth.
- Gram -- which also means 'wrath' in its original language -- is a famous blade from Germanic mythology. The blade Gram is embedded into a tree by the god Odin, who noted that only a worthy hero can pull it out. The blade would be drawn by the hero Sigurd (a.k.a. Siegfried) to slay the evil dragon Fafnir in the Nibelung Saga.
- The Axe of Xingtian refers to the Chinese myth of an axe-wielding divine giant. Xingtian was a rebel against the supreme god, who was decapitated for his rebellion. Refusing to let a simple thing as death stop him, Xingtian survived as a headless being, using his nipples as eyes and his navel as a mouth, continuing to fight beyond death.
- Bohu (or Vohu) and Tohu are terms from the Hebrew Bible about the void that exists prior to the creation of light by God. The subtitles for Bohu and Tohu identify them as "Blade of Nothingness" and "Blade of Chaos" respectively.
- Honebami Toshiro is a a Japanese katana, attributed to one of the greatest swordsmiths in Japanese history, Toshiro (Awataguchi Yoshimitsu). The sword is now in a shrine in Kyoto, and gained its reputation for the ability to crush or sever bones as if 'devouring' them.
- Muramasa is a famous Japanese swordsmith from the 14th-16th century, whose swords are well-known for their supreme quality... but also often had myths of them being cursed blades.

