Daredevil, Born Again, Season 2, Episode 8: The Southern Cross
Okay, that's an... all right ending? It's not as epic as episode 7's big Daredevil and Kingpin fight. And mostly, I think, is that once again, like any big Marvel project, they see the need to inject a massive big epic action showpiece. Which really ends up bringing in some huge logic leaps, at least from how I reacted to it.
Basically, I felt like the courtroom scene was neat. Again, not sure if it makes sense legally or not, but I'm willing to suspend my disbelief that Matthew Murdock revealing that he is Daredevil and how he could corroborate the evidence from the dead sailor guy from the Northern Star is a very cool moment. The tense dialogue between Matt and Wilson; Matt's huge speech as people yell out 'overruled' and 'sustained'... pretty nice performances. Kingpin gets to give a speech; Heather and Karen get to trade some barbs as well, and Hochberg is a fun, smarmy antagonist. And of course, the "I'm Daredevil" moment, followed up by him doing wacky billy-club stunts in the courtroom. It's a great moment, and a nice bit of Matt using Kingpin's own pride and machinations against him.
The ending is also something that, in a vacuum, I like -- Matthew Murdock won the trial and saved Karen, but his revelation as Daredevil ended him in jail. Meanwhile, Kingpin failed to humiliate Karen and lost his mayorship, but took a deal from the government and lives a peaceful life in exile... but he's alone, looking at the beach. Love is a prison he never expected to be trapped in without Vanessa.
But inserting a gratuitous action scene in the middle, with very explicit scenes of Kingpin finally letting loose and murdering protestors -- extremely violently, too! -- between those scenes? And Daredevil making Kingpin accept the government deal... in front of an angry mob? And Wilson, who's spent the lat three episodes refusing to accept reason over revenge... agrees, what the heck? I felt like none of these scenes really worked logically, and I felt like that kind of ruined the finale a bit.
The season has been building up to the discussion of Daredevil's mercy and what he shows to Kingpin and Bullseye, but... it's just weird. Matt forgives Kingpin and that's a good thing for Matt's moral compass, but it's just so weird that Matt doesn't see this as Wilson crossing over a massive line -- a massive line made up by the blood of a couple dozen random protesting youths he just leaped across. Even if he's all about due procedure, what about those brand-new deaths? What about the deaths of Daniel Blake, Commissioner Gallo, Hector Ayala, and all the people that the AVTF brutalized? Again, there is a way to keep Kingpin alive for another season and still say something about the themes of the show, but this one is just a bit muddled.
Bullseye's freedom didn't just last for the subdued moment of saving the governor, either. He walks up, slaughters a contingent of AVTF trying to masquerade as him (ironic, considering Bullseye pretended to be Daredevil in season 3), and instead of taking a shot at Matt as he walks out of the courtroom, Bullseye tries to kill Kingpin... and kills Buck instead? Or at least wounds him that he gets some tender scenes later with Wilson and Heather. Did he die? We didn't get the confirmation.
Speaking of Buck, Kingpin's little supporting cast... really ended up not doing quite as much, as it seems like they're out. Sheila just kind of disappears this season, and ends up being the one sane person that ends up entirely unscathed. Buck is (maybe?) dead. Blake is dead. Heather throat-chops the asshole DA Hochberg, and later ends up donning the Muse mask properly at the end of the episode. Eh. After how much we built them up across the last two seasons, it really is kind of disappointing.
There are also a bunch of stuff with BB Urich, who ends up also unmasking herself as the Anti-Kingpin videomaker. This led to the gathering of the aforementioned army of protestors wearing Daredevil masks. Mostly it's just an excuse to have Brett Mahoney, Angela del Toro and a bunch of others gather in front of the courtroom. The AVTF storyline also ends very blandly as expected. Powell is a hammy but one-dimensional character, and when he gets to be too much of a jackass, Cole punches him out and lets the protestors in.
(That is a very unconvincing heel-face-turn from Cole, by the way, regarding how he reacted to the Hector order... I really wished there was a bit more obviousness that Saunders' fake death two episodes ago bothered him. There's also nothing about the forgiveness theme between Angela and Cole, which surprises me and makes Angela feel even more like a gratuitous comic-book-character cameo).
There are some other characters that are wrapped up in this episode as well. Jessica Jones ends up sticking around throughout the entirety of this episode, even long enough in court to actually interact with Kingpin, steal the local booze, and do some superstrength people-tossing. Jessica ends up going home to Danielle in Alias Investigations. Also, Luke Cage comes back! Mr. Charles (or 'Mr. Robinson', as he calls himself now) got a new attack dog, and that attack dog is Bullseye.
(Mr. Charles is, by the way, another character that was kind of disappointing and really didn't do much after hamming it up so much. I really wished that he either contributed more to Kingpin's downfall, or properly interacting with Jessica, or if you want to make it a Thunderbolts tie-in be more blatant about it...)
Again... I don't know. I felt like this season finale wasn't terrible, but it was definitely clunky. I felt like it would've been a lot more poetic if Matt/Wilson had the huge fistfight in episode 6, and a huge wordfight in this final episode. Maybe switch them around if Marvel really demands an action-packed finale. Maybe have Matt fight Bullseye or something. A lot of the themes about forgiveness and mercy really do end up muddled a lot, and a lot of the side characters really ended up not doing much. The huge long-term 'conspiracy thread' of Mayor Fisk being in cahoots with the government and the Red Port/Northern Star also didn't end up amounting to much, which is another slight disappointment. Ditto for the 'voice of the people', which took up so much space in the first two episodes, and was abandoned until now BB comes out and rallies a whole army of protestors. It would've been a lot more authentic if this was done a bit better, a bit more gradual, and maybe in place of some of the less interesting supporting characters.
Again... I did enjoy watching these episodes. But there definitely is a sad step-down in terms of narrative consistency compared to the previous season. I don't know how much attempts to mirror and/or distance itself from real-life American politics has affected the writing here, and that might be fair on the portrayal of Mayor Kingpin or the AVTF... but there really are a lot of parts of this season that didn't work as well as it should. Oh well.
Marvel Easter Eggs Corner:
- Luke Cage appears after last being seen at the conclusion of his own show, which left at a cliffhanger; and then having a brief cameo in Jessica Jones's final episode.
- Mitchell Ellison makes a return after last being seen in Daredevil season 3, although his name was glimpsed in BB's phone earlier this season. The office that he gives BB was the one used by Ben Urich in season 1.
- Speaking of old sets, Jessica Jones revisits the set of Alias Investigations, albeit having renovated it to being more baby-friendly.
- Fisk begins a speech with 'when I was a boy', which is a phrase he repeats a couple of times throughout the original Daredevil when discussing his past.
- In the comics, Daredevil did go to prison after his identity was leaked, in the "Devil in Cell-Block D" story arc.
- In the comics, Bullseye has worked for the government several times -- once as a nanite-controlled villain under Iron Man in Civil War, and more well-known as the 'Hawkeye' of Norman Osborn's Dark Avengers/Thunderbolts team.